Round Duct Flange Forming: Ring Rolling, Welds and Flatness

2026-11-19

I once watched two round duct sections come back from a site in Jeddah because the flanges would not bolt together. Each ring was within tolerance on paper. Put them face to face and the bolt holes were out by 14 mm at the top. The rolling operator had measured the circumference with a tape and called it good; nobody had checked for ovality or flatness after welding.

Round flange work is full of small measurements that only matter at assembly time. Get them right in the shop and installation is boring, which is exactly what you want.

How the ring is made

Most round duct flanges start as a flat strip of 4 to 8 mm mild steel, or as an angle profile when the duct is large. The strip goes through a three-roller rolling machine, where the two bottom rolls support it and the top roll presses down to curve it. The ends are joined by welding, the ring is checked for roundness, then the bolt holes are punched or drilled on a radial arm or a dedicated line.

The three-roller machine is simple and forgiving, but it has one weakness: the last 40 to 60 mm at each end never passes through the rolls properly. If you do not pre-bend those ends, the finished ring has two flat spots where the ends meet, and no amount of adjusting the top roll will remove them.

Pre-bending the ends

Feed the strip in from one side until about 50 mm protrudes past the nip, roll a shallow curve, reverse, and do the same on the other end. Then roll the full length in three or four passes, tightening the top roll a little each time. If you try to reach the final radius in one pass, the strip springs back unevenly and you will chase the diameter for an hour.

Springback on 5 mm mild steel is roughly 3 to 5 percent of the target diameter. Roll to about 0.96 of the finished diameter and let the ring relax before measuring. On stainless it is worse, around 7 percent, and on aluminium it varies with temper.

Sizing the ring: numbers that hold up

The strip width for a flat ring is the flange face width plus about 3 mm for weld shrink and trimming. Bolt holes go on a pitch circle 15 to 20 mm in from the outer edge for a 40 mm face.

Duct diameterStrip thicknessFlange face widthBolt holesHole sizeOvality limit
200–400 mm4 mm30 mm8–129 mm2 mm
450–700 mm5 mm40 mm12–169 mm3 mm
800–1,200 mm6 mm50 mm16–2411 mm4 mm
1,250–1,600 mm8 mm60 mm24–3213 mm5 mm
Above 1,600 mm8 mm angle ring65 mm32+13 mm6 mm

Hole count is not arbitrary. Aim for 150 to 200 mm between holes around the circumference. Fewer holes and the gasket compresses unevenly; more holes and you spend all day bolting a joint that did not need that many bolts. On a 1,000 mm ring, 20 holes gives you a pitch of about 157 mm, which is about right.

Measuring diameter without lying to yourself

A tape measure around the outside is the least reliable method because it follows the surface rather than the pitch circle, and it tightens unevenly in the operator's hands. Measure across two diagonals with a rigid bar, then roll the ring on a flat table and check the gap under a straightedge to find ovality. For high-value work, measure the pitch circle diameter with an inside caliper and record it.

Two diagonals at 90 degrees that differ by more than the ovality limit mean the ring needs re-rolling. Do not try to correct it by welding the joint under tension. That produces a ring that measures round on the bench and springs out of shape as soon as it is cut free.

Welding the joint without distorting the ring

The ends meet at a butt joint. Clamp them with a small bridge piece, tack at the bottom, middle and top, then weld from the bottom up in two short passes. Do not run one continuous bead from one end to the other; the heat input pulls the ring towards the weld and you lose 3 or 4 mm of roundness at the joint.

On a 6 mm ring, a 3.2 mm electrode at about 110 A works well. Let the ring cool before you touch the rollers again. Welding a ring while it is still hot and then rolling it introduces stress that comes out later, usually during hole punching.

Where the duct is thin or the specification calls for it, a spot welder can attach the flange to the duct body with fewer heat marks than stick welding. Spots at 100 to 150 mm intervals around the circumference are enough on duct up to 1,000 mm; above that, add a stitch every third spot for stiffness.

Grinding and flatness

Grind the weld flush on both faces. A proud weld of even 1 mm stops the flange sitting flat on its mating ring and forces the gasket to close an uneven gap. After grinding, lay the ring on a surface plate or a known flat table and check with a straightedge in four positions. The limit I use is 1.5 mm across the face for rings up to 1,200 mm, and 2.5 mm above that.

If the ring is out of flat, check the weld first, then the rolling. A ring that was rolled with the top roll tilted will come out of the machine with a slight cone shape, and no amount of grinding will fix that. Re-roll it with the roll parallel to the bottom pair.

Fixing the ring to the duct

Slip the ring over the duct end and check the fit before welding. There should be 1 to 2 mm of clearance all the way round. More than 3 mm and the spot weld has to bridge a gap, which produces a weak joint that cracks when the duct is lifted.

On large ducts I use a simple expanding jig made from a ring of flat bar and eight screws. It pushes the duct out to meet the flange evenly and holds it while the first spots go in. It cost USD 120 to make and has paid for itself many times over on 1,250 mm work.

Seal the interface with a continuous mastic bead before fixing. Once the ring is welded all the way round, there is no way to get sealant into that gap, and a 1 mm annular gap around a 1,000 mm duct is a real leakage path.

Quality control: five checks per batch

Pitch circle diameter. Two diagonals, recorded on the batch sheet. Tolerance plus or minus 2 mm below 700 mm, plus or minus 4 mm above.

Ovality. Ring on a flat table, straightedge across, feeler gauge under. See the table above for limits by diameter.

Flatness of the face. Straightedge in four positions after grinding. This catches a welded ring that pulled out of plane.

Hole alignment. Stack two rings from the same batch and pass a rod through four holes at 90 degrees. If the rod binds, the holes were drilled after the ring was distorted or the indexing was wrong.

Weld integrity. Visual check for undercut and porosity, then a tap test with a small hammer. A dull note next to the joint means a crack. On pressure work, dye penetrant on the first article of each batch is worth the twenty minutes.

What usually goes wrong

The ring is oval after welding

Heat distortion from a single long weld. Change the sequence to two short passes and let it cool between them. If it has already happened, re-roll gently with the weld at the top roll position.

Holes do not line up between two rings

Almost always because one ring was drilled before it was fully cooled or before the joint was ground. Drill after welding and grinding, every time, and use the same fixture for both rings.

The flange sits proud on one side of the duct

The duct itself is out of round. A flange cannot straighten a duct; it only follows it. Check the duct end with the same straightedge before slipping the ring on, and re-roll the duct if needed.

Rings rust at the weld within a month

The weld scale was not cleaned and the area was not repainted. Wire-brush the heat-affected zone back to bright metal and apply a zinc-rich primer before the ring leaves the shop.

Tooling for holes, and the indexing trap

Bolt holes are usually punched on a radial-arm setup where the ring is clamped to a rotating table and indexed by hand. The trap is that the ring rarely sits concentric with the table. A 2 mm offset at the clamp shows up as a 4 mm variation in hole position around the circle, and the error repeats on every ring made with the same fixture. Check concentricity with a dial gauge before the first hole, not after the batch.

On 4 and 5 mm strip a punch gives a clean hole with a die clearance of about 0.35 mm. The burr that comes with punching needs a quick deburr with a hand scraper, because a burr on the mating face stops the two rings sitting flat and cuts the gasket. On 8 mm plate I switch to drilling with a cobalt bit at low speed; the hole costs more but the face stays clean.

Drill or punch after the weld has cooled and after grinding. I have seen a shop drill 200 rings, then discover that the grinding step was pulling the joint 3 mm out of position, which made every one of those rings a reject. Sequence is cheaper than precision.

When angle ring beats flat bar

An angle ring has a vertical leg that resists bending in the plane of the joint, so it stays flat under bolting load. Flat bar relies on its thickness alone. On a 1,500 mm ring with 32 bolts, tightening the bolts sequentially can bow a flat bar ring by several millimetres; an angle ring of the same thickness barely moves. If the specification calls for more than 24 bolts, the angle profile is usually the cheaper route once rework is counted.

FAQ

Flat bar or angle ring for a 1,200 mm duct?

Flat bar is cheaper and fine up to about 1,200 mm if the face is 50 mm and the thickness is 6 mm. Above that, an angle ring is much stiffer and will stay flat during handling. The dedicated flange line forms angle profile rings with less springback than a three-roller machine.

How many passes does a 6 mm ring need?

Three or four, with the top roll tightened 2 to 3 mm each time. More passes work-harden the strip and make springback less predictable; fewer passes leave a polygon rather than a circle.

Can I punch bolt holes instead of drilling them?

Yes on 4 and 5 mm mild steel, with a die clearance around 8 percent of thickness. On 8 mm plate, drill. Punching that thickness leaves a heavy burr and a tapered hole that pulls the bolt off centre.

What tolerance should I put on the drawing?

For general HVAC, plus or minus 3 mm on pitch circle diameter and 3 mm ovality up to 1,200 mm is achievable without special tooling. Tighter than that costs you time on every ring, so only specify it when the joint really needs it.

Read0
share
Write your comment right