A shop outside Ho Chi Minh City tried to save money on a 4,000 m² order by switching from Z275 to Z100 galvanised coil. The saving on the coil was about USD 1,900. By the end of the second shift the lock-forming rolls were picking up zinc, the flange rolls were leaving grey streaks on every part, and the slitting knives needed sharpening twice as often. The order finished with roughly 300 m of visibly marked duct and two sets of rolls sent out for polishing. It was an expensive lesson in how a coating that is only 20 microns thinner can change a whole production line.
Zinc weight is one of those specifications buyers treat as a line on a quotation. It is worth treating as a process parameter instead.
Z275 means 275 grams of zinc per square metre of sheet, measured across both faces. It does not mean 275 microns, or 275 grams per face. Split it across the two sides and convert using the density of zinc, and you get a coating about 19 microns thick on each face. Z100 gives you 100 g/m² total, about 7 microns per face.
| Designation | Total coating (g/m²) | Approx. per face (µm) | Typical use | Coil price index |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Z100 | 100 | 7 | Indoor, dry, short-life duct | 100 |
| Z140 | 140 | 10 | General interior HVAC | 104 |
| Z200 | 200 | 14 | Humid interiors, coastal stores | 108 |
| Z275 | 275 | 19 | Exterior, marine, long-life plant | 113 |
The price index in that table is indicative, based on the quotes I have seen over the last two years. On a 1.0 mm coil the jump from Z100 to Z275 is roughly 8 to 13 percent, which sounds manageable until you set it against the cost of a roll regrind and a week of rejected parts.
Two coils both labelled Z275 can behave differently. What matters is how evenly the zinc is distributed and how well it is bonded. A coil with a heavy but loose coating will flake under a forming roll; a tighter, thinner coating will sometimes perform better. Ask for the mill certificate, and when you change supplier, run a test coil through the line before committing to a container.
Zinc is soft. At room temperature it shears easily, and under pressure it smears into a thin film that reduces friction between the sheet and the tool. Up to a point that is good: it is why galvanised sheet runs through a roll former with less heat and less tool wear than bare steel.
The point is contact pressure. When the roll gap is too tight, or the roll has a rough surface, the pressure exceeds what the coating can carry. Zinc transfers onto the roll face, builds up in ridges, and then prints those ridges back onto every part. That is pick-up, and once it starts it gets worse with every metre because the build-up raises the contact pressure further.
Z100 reaches that point sooner than Z275. There is simply less zinc available to replenish the film, and the thinner coating is more easily displaced. On a lock-forming stand, Z100 typically starts showing pick-up after 600 to 1,200 m; Z275 will often run 3,000 m or more between cleans. Those numbers shift with speed and roll finish, but the direction never changes.
A polished roll at Ra 0.4 µm will carry a zinc film and release the sheet cleanly. A roll at Ra 1.6 µm, or one with a grinding pattern running across the sheet direction, will tear the coating. When a shop complains that a new coil marks the parts, I check the rolls before I blame the coil. Nine times out of ten a recent roll regrind left a coarse finish.
On the three-station line, the flanging rolls see the highest pressure because they are forming a 20 mm pocket in one pass. That is where pick-up starts first. A weekly wipe with a soft cloth and a light mineral spirit is cheaper than a regrind.
These figures come from a 1.0 mm sheet at 18 m/min on a line with TDF flanging and Pittsburgh lock rolls. Treat them as a starting point, not a guarantee; your roll geometry and speed will move them.
| Metric | Z100 | Z140 | Z275 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roll cleaning interval | Every 600–1,200 m | Every 1,500–2,000 m | Every 3,000–4,000 m |
| Visible marking after a long run | Common | Occasional | Rare |
| Slitting knife sharpening interval | 8 tonnes | 12 tonnes | 18 tonnes |
| Weld current needed, relative | 100% | 103% | 110% |
| Scrap from coating damage | 2.5–4% | 1–2% | Below 1% |
The slitting result surprised me the first time I measured it. Heavier coating means more zinc on the knife edge, and zinc is abrasive to a high-carbon blade over time, but the extra lubrication more than compensates. On a power slitter, changing from Z100 to Z275 extended knife life from about 8 tonnes of coil to 18 tonnes in one shop I track.
Everything above assumes 18 m/min. Run at 30 m/min and the contact temperature at the roll rises, the zinc film thins, and pick-up arrives roughly 40 percent sooner. If you need the speed for a delivery, budget for more frequent cleaning or accept more marking. You cannot have both without changing the roll finish or the coating.
Zinc boils well below the temperature of the weld pool. All that coating around a seam has to go somewhere, which is why galvanised duct welding produces fumes and why porosity is a constant risk. The heavier the coating, the more gas you have to deal with.
In practice I raise the current by about 10 percent for Z275 over Z100 on the same gauge, slow the travel slightly, and keep the arc short. The extra heat pushes the zinc away from the pool instead of trapping it. Fume extraction is not optional: a long seam on Z275 in a closed shop will fill the bay with zinc oxide smoke in minutes, and the operators will feel it by the end of the shift.
Grind the coating back 15 mm either side of a butt weld before joining on stainless or mixed-material work. On galvanised-to-galvanised joints, a light wire-brush pass is enough and saves the time.
On a 4,000 m² job using 0.8 mm sheet, the coil weighs roughly 25 tonnes. Moving from Z100 to Z275 at a 10 percent premium costs about USD 2,000 at a USD 800/tonne base price. That is the number that made the purchasing manager in Ho Chi Minh City reach for the lighter coil.
Against it: two roll regrinds at USD 180, an extra 2.5 percent scrap on 25 tonnes which is 625 kg of sheet worth USD 500, and roughly six hours of production time lost to cleaning and rework. At a line rate of USD 90 an hour that is another USD 540. The total is around USD 1,400 to USD 1,800, before you count the damaged reputation of 300 m of streaked duct. The heavier coil was the cheaper choice, and not by a small margin.
The calculation flips on very short runs. If you are making 300 m² of duct that will be installed in a dry plant room and painted over, Z100 is fine, and the pick-up never has time to build. Coating choice is a function of run length as much as service life.
Put three things on the purchase order: the coating class, the mill certificate, and the surface finish of the coil. Ask for a test coil of two or three tonnes on a new supplier, run it through the line, and measure how many metres you get before the rolls need a wipe. That single test tells you more than a certificate.
Store coil off the floor with the wrap intact until the day it is used. A Z275 coil left in a humid container for six weeks will develop white rust on the outer wrap regardless of its coating weight, and the first 20 m of that coil will mark every roll it touches.
Cleaning rolls sounds simple and is usually done badly. Wiping a roll with a rag soaked in solvent while the line is stopped removes the loose zinc but polishes the build-up into the surface, which makes the next pick-up worse. The routine that works in the shops I visit has four steps.
First, stop the line and let the rolls cool. Warm zinc smears. Second, use a soft brass brush or a non-woven pad with a light mineral spirit, and wipe in the direction of the roll rotation, never across the grinding marks. Third, inspect the roll with a finger under a good light: any ridge you can feel is still there and will print. Fourth, run a 2 m test piece through and look at it before restarting the batch.
Write the metre count on a card next to the stand. A shop that knows it cleaned at 2,400 m will clean again at 5,000 m; a shop that relies on memory waits until the parts are visibly marked, by which time several hundred metres have been affected. On a line running 18 m/min, that discipline is worth more than any coating upgrade.
Take two metres of the trial coil and pass it through the line at production speed. Stop, look at the roll faces under a torch, and pass another two metres. If you see any transfer on the roll after 4 m, run the same test at a gap 0.1 mm wider. If the marks persist, the coating is too loosely bonded for your rolls, regardless of what the certificate says. That test has caught more bad coils for me than any incoming inspection.
Usually not. Z140 is adequate for that service, and on short runs it forms more cleanly than people expect. Save Z275 for exterior, coastal, or long-life installations, and for long production runs where roll pick-up drives the cost.
Flange rolls apply the highest local pressure. If the marks start there, reduce the roll gap slightly, check the surface finish, and clean the roll. If the marks are across the whole sheet, the problem is more likely contaminated coil or a damaged roll upstream.
Physically yes, visually no. Different coatings take weld current differently and age differently, so a joint between Z100 and Z275 will show a line after a few months outdoors. Keep a job on one coating.
No. Beading failures on galvanised sheet come from a bead that is too deep for the gauge, not from the zinc. If anything, the extra lubrication helps the beading rolls release the sheet more cleanly.
One last practical note: tell the operator which coil is loaded. A simple whiteboard entry with the coil number, coating class and metre count turns pick-up from a mystery into a number you can manage.